Casey's
Casey's is a small bar in Ann Arbor, on Depot, across from the train station. I had heard from multiple credible sources that they had an excellent burger. Last Friday, after enlisting my friend Bret, I set out to investigate.
Interior decoration at Casey's is heavily sports themed (best evidenced by the innumerable trophies collected on shelves above the bar), with a hint of generic Americana (My table was literally directly under an American Flag). The graphic on the menu isn't a baseball, but when I looked at it, I couldn't help but think about baseball.
The menu at Casey's, and Bret. Not in that order.
I hesitate to call it a sports bar, though, possible because it had more of an old-time feel than any sports bar I've ever been to before. Said old time feel was not ruined by the presence of multiple flatscreen TVs showing various feats Olympic. Bret's comment: "When I hear the word 'Tavern,' this is what I think of."
There was a bit of a wait to get in, which I suppose is to be expected on a Friday. Our waiter made it very clear to us that he wanted to take our order, not listen to our story, nor waste our time with his.
But this is the Burger Blog, why am I wasting your valuable reading time with descriptions of the burger venue? The answer is that frankly, the burger wasn't much to write home about. I say 'home' for a reason; a number of times, the burger had an active blandness that I associate strongly with burgers I make in the broiler at home. I'm going to repeat that. The thing that this highly acclaimed burger that I made a trip to Ann Arbor for reminded me of the most is something I can (and do) make for myself every night, without leaving the house.
I don't want to come down too hard on Casey's. The burger had a lot of upsides. It was Juicy, with a very absorbent bun, and those two qualities combined, leading to awesome. Toward the end, there was a bit of a charred taste (the good kind). The burger definitely ended better than it started.
The fries were fairly standard, the kind of fries that are sometimes called french fries, and sometimes called steak fries. They were a bit well done. A solid side.
The big test, would I eat there again? I wouldn't object to it, but I don't think I'll actively seek another burger at Casey's.
This is what the Casey's sign looks like when you've had a few.